Which Brand Wins?
Transcript*
Intro
Hello all. This is David from Loisirs vers le soleil and today I thought about talking about something a little different. And by a little different [music] I mean not different at all as I will be talking about planes. Last night as I was scrubbing each individual toe in the shower, a thought had occurred to me. Who makes the best Mustang kit? Considering that for as long as plastic scale models have been around, literally every single manufacturer who makes planes has made a Mustang kit at one point or another.
So, in today’s video, I thought I would compile [music] pretty much every Mustang kit that we sell, take a quick look inside each one, and at the end of the video, determine which one, in my [music] opinion, is the best. And as we all know, my opinion is very important. First, let’s start with the worst.
Revell 85-5535
I know for a fact that this one will not win our contest in the slightest. In fact, if I were ranking this kit’s attractiveness on a scale of 1 to 10, it would be -10. Well, maybe that’s a little harsh. -9. All right, let’s open this up. Ah, all the markings of a lousy kit. Flash galore. Raised panel lines. subpar detail. I mean, [music] at least the raised rivets are accurate. The decal sheet seems fine. I think that’s the only thing in here that’s not 50 years old. So, they do include an engine in there. Looks to be no more than 10 parts. 10 [music] flash riddled parts.
Oh, don’t you love it when they cut the pilot [music] down the middle in half. And that is all the detail you get in the cockpit. You get a back [music] half of the seat, the bottom half fused into the cockpit floor, an instrument panel, and a control stick. So, [music] hardly brimming with detail. And then, uh, they thought that’s good enough. You can close up the fuselage. For a 1/32nd scale kit today, this is completely unacceptable. [music] Now, yes, I know this is a very old kit and it’s also a kit that’s been around. It’s been re-boxed many times. I mean, unless you’re one of those guys who says that you have to suffer to be considered a good modeler, this one’s for you. But any other more sensible people, pass on it. That one was pretty much the only hideous kit in our selection.
Revell 03944
So with that abomination out of the way, we can now move on and I will be looking at each kit by scale. So [music] sticking with 1/32 scale, we have Revell’s more modernized Mustang. Looks like in this case the oversized boxes [music] was needed. So the parts count on this one looks a lot more in tune. Parts look pretty nice. I don’t see any flash this time. They have nice recessed panel lines. However, there don’t seem to be many rivets. I mean, if there is one thing [music] that that old Revell kit has over this is the rivet detail, but that’s all I’m going to give it.
Well, look at this. Uh, there actually is some flash here, right in that corner there. So, definitely not as bad as the older one, but it’s still there. decals look pretty good. If they’re printed in Italy, then they’re most likely Cartograph. [music] Yeah, this time the cockpit has a little more effort put into it. Instead of one little section on one page, it’s about [music] two pages, 2 and 1/2 pages worth. This one doesn’t have an engine for you to build. Yeah. So, a lot more steps to this one. This feels more like a [music] modern 1/32nd scale aircraft kit. Yeah, this one has its issues, but it’s serviceable.
Tamiya 60322
Now, for our last 1/32nd scale Mustang, [music] and it may very well be our contender for the best, Tamiya. [music] So, right when you open the box, you already see care [music] as they have placed a few parts in protective boxes such as the engine cowlings. [music] And this box here is all the clear parts as well as a screwdriver, some poly caps, some metal rods, some screws and nuts, uh rubber tires, and a photo-etch fret [music] on this one. Beautiful surface detail, both recessed and raised. It’s [music] recessed where it needs to be. You get uh two figures with it. Looks [music] like an officer which can be posed standing with the plane and a pilot. And he’s not split down the middle. He is split in all the places he needs to be.
You have parts for a full Merlin [music] engine. You get a full colour page of the first marking option. You also get a little booklet talking a bit about the [music] plane in uh Japanese and English. They even give you some reference photos for your work. That is [music] very nice of them. Saves you having to research it all yourself. You get canopy [music] masks as well as a name plate for display purposes. Your decal sheet. Surprisingly not that big for a 32 scale aircraft and a thick instruction book. I’m not going to bother going through the whole thing. It’ll take me forever.
But what’s important to know is it is a fully detailed cockpit, a fully detailed engine which you can display if you like, a fully detailed [music] gun bays as well, and wheel wells. So, literally every single thing you need is already in here. Uh, no need for aftermarket. [music] It’s early, but we may already have our winner.
Airfix 14001V
Let’s move on to our one and only 1/24th scale offering [music] of a Mustang. I doubt I’ll be able to fit it all in the frame. It’s Airfix’s Mustang. That doesn’t sound good. I know I gave old Revell one a tough time, but uh this is old air fix, [music] but it is 1/24th scale, so it can’t be that bad. So, it all comes in a very large bag. There are some parts in there that are bagged individually [music] as well. Look at that flash. It It’s almost [music] mutated some of the parts. Oh, boy. At least it’s got recessed panel lines. Okay, so there’s our instructions.
The decal sheet, at least is from this century. The booklet feels quite thin for an aircraft of this size. The engine looks to have, I guess, a serviceable amount of detail on it. the cockpit. This looks like the cockpit of an average 1/72 scale craft. So, they do let you display the engine and the gun belts and all that, but considering how the parts looked in the bag. I don’t know if you’d even want to [music] do that. And it’s got colour illustrations for two marking options. All right. So, which is worse? This one or the old Revel one? I got to say, it’s still the old Revell. At least this one tries to add more detail to it. [music] It just kind of fails at it. But yeah, the uh if I gave the Old Revell a negative N out of 10, this would be a negative eight.
Édouard
All right, next up is my favourite, the Big E, Eduard. And this will be the first of our 1/48 scale Mustangs. Now, full disclosure, this is from my own personal stash. We don’t carry this specific Eduard kit, but we do have a few other 1/48 steel Mustangs from Eduard. Uh they’re just not in stock right now, but uh we are working on that. We’ll hopefully get it back very soon. I mean, they’re all just reboxes of each other anyway. So, whatever you see in here won’t be that different from what we actually carry. [music] So, anyway, speaking from experience, I know already that this kit is awesome.
You got your clear parts. Now, um, one criticism of Eduards, a very minor one, it really has nothing to do with anything on their part, but there always seems to be a loose clear part in their [music] kits. I guess the uh where that they join on the sprue tree, they’re just too fragile. So, this always happens. [music] The surface detail is honestly equal to [music] the Tamiya 1/32nd scale one that we looked at earlier. Beautifully recessed. Same thing here. Great details and Eduard most of the time do tend to be the most accurate depictions of aircraft. So everything in here should be true to the actual plane. A nice big decal sheet for the six different marking options in this one. A photo-etch fret with a few pre-coloured parts.
A die-cut canopy [music] mask, which that’s another uh edge over the Tamiya one. Uh you have to [music] cut those yourself. Eduard’s instructions are always very nice and informative. Sometimes they can even be a little overwhelming if you’re not an expert, but uh that’s no problem for guys like us. So, lots of detail in the cockpit. A lot of detail in the [music] wheel bay as well. And honestly, not too many assembly steps [music] either. So, it it’s detailed, but not too time consuming. And beautiful full colour illustrations of each marking [music] scheme.
Tamiya 61044
So, this would be my second contender for the best kit. And for our second 1/48 scale kit, we’ve got Tamiya. Again, I expect all the same praises from the 1/32 scale one to be here as well. Surface detail is almost as good as the 1/32 scale offering. [music] I think the Eduard one is a tad bit better if you ask me. But uh one edge I will give Tamiya over Eduard, at least in the 1/48 scale department, I love [music] the Tamiya always includes a pilot. Eduard never does.
And for a somewhat older kit, I believe this is from the early or mid90s, that pilot looks quite [music] good. So cockpit has a moderate amount of detail. You could always get aftermarket if you wanted to to spice it up some more, but this is usually enough for most people and [music] not too many steps. So again, easy to put together. If you wanted to, you could finish this in a weekend. And three marking schemes for this kit. [music] So also a pretty good contender. And we’re now moving on to our last scale, the 1/72 scale [music] Mustangs.
Tamiya 60749
Starting with Tamiya. May as well finish them off. So [music] the Tamiya 1/72nd scale aircraft are usually just scaled down versions of their 1/48 scale ones, just with uh fewer parts. More of them are already moulded into the plastic as opposed to separate parts to glue together. But they still have a good amount of surface [music] detail on them. Makes for a cute little Mustang. Small decor sheet for, I believe, two [music] marking schemes. And the booklet pretty similar to the 1/48 scale, just with, like I said, a fewer parts, but it does still manage to [music] replicate the same amount of detail as their larger 1/48 steel one. So for [music] 1/72 scale, we’re off to a good start.
Italeri 086
Next, we have Italeri. I’m not expecting much from this one, but [music] let’s take a look. We got two sprues in this bag. Surface detail [music] is adequate. There’s no rivets anywhere, [music] but at least the panel lines are recessed. I mean, so the surface detail is serviceable. You could always [music] add rivets yourself if you want to make it more realistic. Here’s your decal sheet with two marking options. Got your little booklet here. So, cockpit is very basic, just a seat, a control stick, and an instrument panel. Uh, no sidewall detail at all. So, in the detail department, it’s not great. [music] But if you’re a beginner or you just want to throw something together really quickly, [music] it’s not bad. I mean, I was honestly expecting worse, but uh yeah, [music] I’d put this maybe in the middle of the road.
Airfix 2047A
Here we have the Airfix 1/72 scale Mustang. Thankfully, this is one of the more modern Airfix releases uh in like the past 10, 15 years, so it shouldn’t be awful. Yeah, surface detail is about on par with the Italeri one. Although I I can [music] see that at least there is some cockpit sidewall detail on this one. Also comes with a little pilot. Here’s your decor sheet with two marking options and your foldable instructions. Yeah, cockpit detail similar to the Italeri one. Not too many [music] steps. So, this one’s maybe only slightly better than the Italeri one. [music] So, again, I’d put it in the middle.
Revell 04148
Only one kit left on the chopping block. That is Revell’s 1/72nd scale Mustang. Is that [music] uh raised? Boy, this [music] doesn’t look good. It’s got flash on it, but the odd thing is it’s not a lot of flash, but the proportions are off here. This Mustang looks kind of warped. Well, this one’s not winning. [music] All right, there’s the decal sheet. Probably the only good thing in this kit. [music] Just when I thought those other kits had the worst cockpit details, this one doesn’t even have a control stick [music] on it.
It’s literally just a seat attached [music] to a bulkhead, which is inaccurate to the real Mustang, [music] and an instrument panel. Who did Revell even make this? Th those wheel coverings are completely [music] misshapen. My god, in terms of accuracy, this one may be the worst. [music] Okay, that does it. We’ve looked at every one of them.
David’s Elimination
Now, [music] let’s see who wins. In conclusion, the question still remains, who makes the best Mustang kit? Well, that question is a little harder to answer than you’d think. [music] As like everything, it’s all subjective. There are some people who would think that the easier to build kit is the best, or there are others who think the more detailed and [music] accurate one is the best. So, to make this decision a little easier, why don’t we eliminate all [music] the clear losers of this competition? Revel scale. Revell 1/32nd scale and Airfix 1/24th scale. Airfix 1/72 scale.
Okay, but no. Italeri 1/72 scale. Okay, but definitely not the best. Here’s where it gets a little harder. Revell 1/32 scale. Pretty decent actually. But considering there’s still a little flash, I would have to eliminate this [music] one too. I’m going to have to say Tamiya 1/72 scale. Although it has [music] everything that makes a Tamiya kit great, the detail compared to others [music] is a little lacking. So I will have to eliminate them too. It’s all [music] just my opinion from here on essentially. Tamiya 1/48 scale. Great [music] detail, easy to put together. Literally nothing to complain about here, but [music] it’s not my pick. Which leaves us with the final two. My boy Édouard or the incredibly packed [music] Tamiya 1/32 scale. [sighs]
The Winner
This is like choosing your favourite child. It pains me to go against [music] my favourite, but I’m going to have to say that the Tamiya 1/32nd scale P-51D Mustang is the best Mustang kit [music] out there. Amazing detail. Everything you need is included. Not to mention, [music] Tamiya is very generous with the resource information as well as how [music] carefully they package it. There is literally nothing to complain about here. So, [music] Tamiya 1/32nd scale is my winner. [music] So, thank you very much for watching this video.
Please let us know in the comments who do you think makes the best Mustang kit. And it can be a manufacturer that we don’t sell. Feel free to throw out any name you want, except Frog. Don’t say Frog. You know you’re lying. All of the Mustang kits I have showcased here, you can purchase at Loisirs vers le soleil in store or online. Thank you very much for watching this video. Remember to like, comment, subscribe, follow us on our socials, and until the next one, adios.
About the Author:
David Peckam has built scale models since he was 12, specializing largely on military aircraft. He is a makeup artist and background actor for films and TV. He enjoys watching hockey and of course, movies. He has an excellent knowledge of hobby products and if you have questions concerning scale model airplanes.
*Video by David Peckham
Video Edited by
Daniela Castellano and Leo Nguyen
Transcript generated by youtube
Edited by Angelo Castellano